TexasKZ wrote:
loudhvx wrote: Because most electrical systems are voltage-based, meaning that it is the voltage that is regulated, any device rated for that voltage will only use whatever current it needs.
A raw LED only uses about 2 to 3 volts, so12v would normally blow it up. To get around that, a simple resistor can be used to reduce the voltage. Another method is to put more of them in series. If one of them needs 2v, six of them in series would use 12v.
But LEDs are extremely sensitive to over-voltage, so normally, they use a combination of multiple LEDs in series plus a resistor. The resistor acts as a ballast. By burning away some power as heat, it can help regulate the voltage to the LED stack. That is, when the bike voltage goes from 12 to 14 volts, the extra current through the resistor increases the voltage drop on the resistor. This way the led stack only sees a slight voltage increase, instead of the full 2v increase.
Nowadays, with really high power leds, you're more likely to see an actual regulator for the led stack.
Well then, does the LED headlight actually reduce the load on the electrical system? The heat sinks on the examples above suggest to me that the load to the bulb is essentially the same, and whatever the LEDs don't need gets wasted as heat. Is that correct?
That depends. Is a 60w LED headlight designed to dissipate 60 watts, or is it designed to produce the equivalent amount of light as a 60w conventional bulb.?
Obviously, if an LED bulb is designed to use 60w, then you won't save any electrical power versus a regular 60w bulb. But there might be a lot more light.
If the LED puts out an equivalent amount of light as a 60w bulb, then the LEDs might use a lot less power to do that, so then you would save electrical power. This is the case with home lighting, and I would assume it may be the same with automotive lighting, but I don't know for sure.
The regulator for an LED would not be like a shunting voltage-regulator. A shunt voltage regulator has to get rid of power because the alternator output is too high. The regulator for the LED bulb would be a series-pass, meaning it regulates the voltage to the bulb by only letting through however much current the bulb needs while monitoring the voltage on the bulb. There are some ways of regulating this that are far more efficient than other ways. Regulating power will always dissipate some amount of heat as wasted power, but a modern, high-frequency switching regulator is more efficient than a passive resistor or even an active transistor. But it costs more in terms of control circuitry, so sometimes a passive resistor is much cheaper even though it wastes a bit more power.
The heatsink may be necessary for the regulator, or it could be to cool the LEDs somehow, and it does indicate some wasted power, but a halogen bulb also gets very hot, and that is energy wasted as heat instead of used as light.