Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?

  • Topper
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
More
16 Nov 2013 19:59 #613213 by Topper
Starter Clutch Heavier Springs? was created by Topper
I've been battling problems with the starter clutch on my 1979 KZ750 for over a year. I've replaced the rollers, springs, caps, flywheel, just about everything.

It all looks fine and after reassembly works great for a while. But a few weeks or months later, the starter clutch will start to miss every once in a while, then get progressively worse until it fails completely. I've triple checked the torque spec on the flywheel bolt, it's spot on.

The springs in the starter clutch have always struck me as a little flimsy. They seem like ball point pen springs. I figured the engineers and Kawasaki knew what they were doing though and just replaced the old with new. But after chasing this problem so long, I've decided to try upgrading to some heavier duty springs.

I found some at the hardware store that are the right diameter. They're a lot stiffer but a tad shorter than the stock springs.

Just wondering if anyone else had tried upgrading these springs. When assembled the starter clutch still seems to function properly. I can turn it one way by hand, but not the other.

Is this a bad idea?

Permanent and perpetual noob.

1979 KZ750 Twin
2009 Kawasaki Versys

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • KZQ
  • Offline
  • Administrator
  • Walking Behind the Corn May Not Be All That!
More
16 Nov 2013 20:07 - 16 Nov 2013 20:08 #613214 by KZQ
Replied by KZQ on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?
Hi Topper,

I'm pretty sure that the springs don't add to the engagement ( grab ) of the starter clutch. They just get the process started until the revs get up there and the centripetal acceleration forces the rollers outward compressing the springs. I have the same bike as you, 79 750 twin. I also replaced the springs and rollers and for a while the clutch worked as if it was new. It still works, it just slips once in a while. I did not replace the sprocket with the boss on it despite the fact that I could see some marks on it. Is that part still available from Ma Kaw?

Bill

www.KZ1300.com
Riders:
1968 BSA 441 Shooting Star, 1970 BSA 650 Lightning, 1974 W3, 1976 KZ900, 1979 KZ750 Twin, 1979 KZ750 Twin Trike, 1981 KZ1300, 1982 KZ1100 Spectre, 2000 Valkyrie, 2009 Yamaha Roadliner S. 1983 GL 1100
Projects:
1985 ZN1300
Last edit: 16 Nov 2013 20:08 by KZQ.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
16 Nov 2013 20:17 #613218 by 650ed
Replied by 650ed on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?
Unfortunately, according to Kawasaki.com it looks like that starter clutch gear has been discontinued. Ed

Attachment 00002_2013-11-16.jpg not found


1977 KZ650-C1 Original Owner - Stock (with additional invisible FIAMM horn)
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Topper
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
More
16 Nov 2013 20:19 #613219 by Topper
Replied by Topper on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?
I've seen the sprocket for sale before (haven't looked recently). My memory is that it was pretty expensive. I don't see any galling or marks on mine and I don't think the boss is worn down. Here it is:


You might be right about the springs not contributing to the engagement of the rollers, but I'm at the point of grasping at straws with this. Could heavier springs do any damage? I could imagine if they don't compress enough they might not release, but when turning by hand, they do release, so I'm hoping it's OK to try.

Permanent and perpetual noob.

1979 KZ750 Twin
2009 Kawasaki Versys
The following user(s) said Thank You: 650ed

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • KZQ
  • Offline
  • Administrator
  • Walking Behind the Corn May Not Be All That!
More
16 Nov 2013 20:21 #613220 by KZQ
Replied by KZQ on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?
Thanks Ed,

Back in the day I had a job for a brief time with a company in San Diego that sprayed metal onto bearing surfaces for jet engines. The process was supposed to add a few thousandths of metal that could then be remachined till the speced size was attained again. Has anybody heard of this or a similar technology that might be applied to build up that gear/boss?

Bill

www.KZ1300.com
Riders:
1968 BSA 441 Shooting Star, 1970 BSA 650 Lightning, 1974 W3, 1976 KZ900, 1979 KZ750 Twin, 1979 KZ750 Twin Trike, 1981 KZ1300, 1982 KZ1100 Spectre, 2000 Valkyrie, 2009 Yamaha Roadliner S. 1983 GL 1100
Projects:
1985 ZN1300

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • KZQ
  • Offline
  • Administrator
  • Walking Behind the Corn May Not Be All That!
More
16 Nov 2013 20:25 - 16 Nov 2013 20:27 #613222 by KZQ
Replied by KZQ on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?
When at rest the springs push the rollers into a space that gets progressively smaller and as long as the relative rotation is in the drive direction the clutch is engaged. When I said I could see marks, they were more along the lines of polishing. If the size of the gear isn't so critical perhaps restoring some microscopic texture would help.

I'm thinking that heavier springs would only delay the release of the clutch, perhaps causing more wear on the gear (boss) and rollers.

Bill

www.KZ1300.com
Riders:
1968 BSA 441 Shooting Star, 1970 BSA 650 Lightning, 1974 W3, 1976 KZ900, 1979 KZ750 Twin, 1979 KZ750 Twin Trike, 1981 KZ1300, 1982 KZ1100 Spectre, 2000 Valkyrie, 2009 Yamaha Roadliner S. 1983 GL 1100
Projects:
1985 ZN1300
Last edit: 16 Nov 2013 20:27 by KZQ.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Topper
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
More
16 Nov 2013 20:28 #613223 by Topper
Replied by Topper on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?

KZCSI wrote: Thanks Ed,

Back in the day I had a job for a brief time with a company in San Diego that sprayed metal onto bearing surfaces for jet engines. The process was supposed to add a few thousandths of metal that could then be remachined till the speced size was attained again. Has anybody heard of this or a similar technology that might be applied to build up that gear/boss?

Bill


You think that's the problem? Is there a wear spec for that gear?

Permanent and perpetual noob.

1979 KZ750 Twin
2009 Kawasaki Versys

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • KZQ
  • Offline
  • Administrator
  • Walking Behind the Corn May Not Be All That!
More
16 Nov 2013 20:40 #613226 by KZQ
Replied by KZQ on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?

www.KZ1300.com
Riders:
1968 BSA 441 Shooting Star, 1970 BSA 650 Lightning, 1974 W3, 1976 KZ900, 1979 KZ750 Twin, 1979 KZ750 Twin Trike, 1981 KZ1300, 1982 KZ1100 Spectre, 2000 Valkyrie, 2009 Yamaha Roadliner S. 1983 GL 1100
Projects:
1985 ZN1300

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

  • Topper
  • Topic Author
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
More
17 Nov 2013 06:23 #613251 by Topper
Replied by Topper on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?
Wow KZCSI, that's amazing! But I sure hope it doesn't come to that. I can't imagine that's very affordable and will probably make the NOS gear I let go on ebay look cheap.

I'm thinking that heavier springs would only delay the release of the clutch


I guess I'm kind of hoping that'll actually help. Usually when the starter clutch fails, I push the start button and I can hear it grab and start to turn the engine over, then it slips and releases before the bike starts.

I realize I'm grasping at straws here, but short of finding a NOS starter gear I'm not sure what else to do.

Permanent and perpetual noob.

1979 KZ750 Twin
2009 Kawasaki Versys

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
17 Nov 2013 07:28 #613259 by 650ed
Replied by 650ed on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?

KZCSI wrote: Thanks Ed,

Back in the day I had a job for a brief time with a company in San Diego that sprayed metal onto bearing surfaces for jet engines. The process was supposed to add a few thousandths of metal that could then be remachined till the speced size was attained again. Has anybody heard of this or a similar technology that might be applied to build up that gear/boss?

Bill


I wonder if the boss could be lightly machined without first adding metal to it. Looking at Topper's excellent video (thanks Topper) the stater clutch assembly is tapered where the rollers contact it (see yellow lines in pic below from video). The image shown is a snapshot of the assembly when Topper is turning it counter-clockwise to show how the rollers tighten against the assembly. Even when the rollers are fully engaged, as they are in the image, there appears to be considerable space left to the right of each roller. So if the diameter of the boss was machined down just a few thousandths the rollers should still fully engage as they moved only slightly further clockwise in the assembly. If might be worth a try if a spare starter clutch gear is available. The second image below shows a new old stock starter gear for a KZ650. While the gear itself is different, the way it operates with the rollers is the same as the KZ750 twin. In the image you can see the original texture of the boss. Ed

Attachment 00003_2013-11-17.jpg not found



Attachment StarterGear.jpg not found


1977 KZ650-C1 Original Owner - Stock (with additional invisible FIAMM horn)
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
17 Nov 2013 13:00 - 17 Nov 2013 18:08 #613285 by bountyhunter
Replied by bountyhunter on topic Starter Clutch Heavier Springs?

Topper wrote: Wow KZCSI, that's amazing! But I sure hope it doesn't come to that..

I bought an entire good used starter clutch assy with sprocket and chain off one of the online dismantlers for something like $80. Turned out I didn't need it so I sold it to somebody here.

If you are replacing parts but still having problems, I wonder if your housing is warped or messed up?

Anyway, buying a complete assy might be better than trying to stick more parts into one that keeps giving you trouble.


The other KZ Twin forum has a ton of info about KZ starter clutch woes, but their server seems to be down.

www.armbell.com/kz400/viewforum.php?f=43&mforum=kz400

1979 KZ-750 Twin
Last edit: 17 Nov 2013 18:08 by bountyhunter.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Powered by Kunena Forum