Turban Wearing Biker Loses Challenge In Court
- reborn650
- Topic Author
- Offline
- User
For those who missed it, a guy claimed that his religion prevented him from wearing a helmet when riding his Harley. Looks like this guy will be selling the bike.
This is one of those rare cases where established laws were upheld by a judge with a backbone that didn't support the argument of (claimed) religious persecution versus the accepted laws of the land. Obviously, the guy bought the bike for the express purpose of challenging the law since he must have known that he couldn't use a turban for head protection.
Personally, I am glad this guy lost his bid to have the law changed because if he had a spill and hit his head, we would have to pay for his medical bills. In Ontario we have universal health care paid for by all of the hard-working, law-abiding taxpayers in our province.
For those who don't think there is still a degree of justice, here is the link.
www.thestar.com/News/Ontario/article/310015
Cheers-Colin Firth-Ontario Canada
-1977 Kz650 Custom bought new by brother. Now with 810 kit, GPz750 cams, intake valves, Mikuni 29 smoothbores, velocity stacks, Dyna Igntion, MAC pipe and other goodies.
-1982 Ferrari 308 GTSi Red/Tan
-Toyota FJ Cruiser - 6 speed tank
-2010 Mazda CX-7 Turbo (my bride's)
-1998 Jeep TJ Wrangler 4.0...
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Duck
- Offline
- User
- e vica na i sau na ga
Personally, I am glad this guy lost his bid to have the law changed because if he had a spill and hit his head, we would have to pay for his medical bills. In Ontario we have universal health care paid for by all of the hard-working, law-abiding taxpayers in our province.
What's the big deal. You already pay medicals bills for alcoholics, meth heads, lard asses, and 'gender correction'.
First the government tells you you can't ride a bike without a helmet because it costs too much if you get hurt. Next thing you know you won't be allowed to ride at all. Give them an inch...
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- The Milkman
- Offline
- User
- Posts: 794
- Thank you received: 194
It's the same as the woman that couldn't get a license because she can't take her face cover off.
Let's quit changing the rules to fit each person.
Post edited by: The Milkman, at: 2008/03/06 19:00
78 650-C2, Stock engine, Jardine 4-2 Exh., 17-38 sprockets, dyna ignition and coils, coil wiring mod, carb mod.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- reborn650
- Topic Author
- Offline
- User
reborn650 wrote:
Personally, I am glad this guy lost his bid to have the law changed because if he had a spill and hit his head, we would have to pay for his medical bills. In Ontario we have universal health care paid for by all of the hard-working, law-abiding taxpayers in our province.
What's the big deal. You already pay medicals bills for alcoholics, meth heads, lard asses, and 'gender correction'.
First the government tells you you can't ride a bike without a helmet because it costs too much if you get hurt. Next thing you know you won't be allowed to ride at all. Give them an inch...
Duck. My point is that this guy is trying to change the law to accomodate his requirements, similar to certain religious groups refusing to have their traditional facial coverings removed for photo ID cards. In my opinion, this is wrong in a democratic political system.
If anything, this decision is an endorsement that riding bikes should be done safely in the eyes of our judicial decision makers and this hopefully bodes well for the future of riding in our country. I must point out that there has never been a discussion about outlawing motorcycles in our country to the best of my knowledge.
As far as our medical system supporting the issues you brought up, you will get no challenge from me on that point. But at least these sick (physical or psychological individuals) aren't trying to make us change the laws for them. They are arguably abusing themselves and also abusing the system which does in fact cost us all in expensive medical resources.
The effectiveness and efficiency of our country's universal health care system versus your country's, is a discussion best saved for another thread as both have their own advantages and drawbacks. I was simply offering some follow-up on this challenge to our existing laws which was closely followed by bike riders in Ontario.
Cheers-Colin Firth-Ontario Canada
Post edited by: reborn650, at: 2008/03/06 20:48
-1977 Kz650 Custom bought new by brother. Now with 810 kit, GPz750 cams, intake valves, Mikuni 29 smoothbores, velocity stacks, Dyna Igntion, MAC pipe and other goodies.
-1982 Ferrari 308 GTSi Red/Tan
-Toyota FJ Cruiser - 6 speed tank
-2010 Mazda CX-7 Turbo (my bride's)
-1998 Jeep TJ Wrangler 4.0...
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Saki Jockey
- Offline
- User
- Posts: 154
- Thank you received: 0
Rob A.
550 A4
GTA,
Ontario, Canada
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- N0NB
- Offline
- User
- Blue handles better
Nate
Nates vintage bike axiom: Riding is the reward for time spent wrenching.
Murphys corollary: Wrenching is the result of time spent riding.
1979 KZ650 (Complete!)
1979 KZ650 SR (Sold!)
1979 KL250 (For sale)
1994 Bayou 400 (four wheel peel )
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- KZDon
- Offline
- User
- Posts: 36
- Thank you received: 2
As soon as it's available I'll get myself a copy of Justice Blacklock's decision. He was a very bright lawyer, and now a better judge.
As for appeal, that will be Badesha's decision. A lawyer for the Ontario Human Rights Commission intervened at this trial, but the Commission is unlikely to carry it further on its own.
And given another pending decision at the Supreme Court of Canada (Keays v Honda) one of the questions will be whether Justice Blacklock even had the jurisdiction to hear the human rights issues in the case. Those issues are normally under the jurisdiction of the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal. I'm still not sure why Badesha was in court rather than in front of the Tribunal. I have no doubt that the very left-leaning Tribunal would have come up with the opposite decision.
Gosh, I'll bet you folks are just salivating over the legal intracies of Ontario human rights legislation and helmet laws
Midland, Ontario, Great White North
2004 650 V-Strom
farewell to 81 KZ550A2 - 82 GS750T - 83 GPz750 - R-Reg GT380 - 76 DT175 - 84 GPz550
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- dkmk
- Offline
- User
- Posts: 282
- Thank you received: 18
Ultimately, riding a motorcycle is a privilege to be earned, and to be done in the context of the law. Religious expression and human rights arguments have no place here. What's next? Refusing to strap your child into a car seat because it violates your religious principles? Sheesh... :whistle:
Northern Ontario
Zapp: "Kif, I'm feeling the Captain's Itch."
Kif: "I'll get the powder, sir."
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- JR
- Offline
- Sustaining Member
- Posts: 2935
- Thank you received: 445
No doubt someone will appeal the judgement.
To Don's point on transferring drivers licences, take it from one who has been there, done that, no it's not easy. I came with an international licence which was good for I think 3 months. Just enough time to start at the beginning and go through the same process as everyone else.
1980 kz750E1, Delkevic exhaust
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Locozuna
- Offline
- User
KZ900LTD, KZ750LTD, KZ650, 72'Triumph Trident
"Over the Mountains
Of the Moon,
Down the Valley of the Shadow,
Ride, boldly ride,"
The shade replied
"If you seek for Eldorado!"
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Patton
- Offline
- KZr Legend
- Posts: 18640
- Thank you received: 2098
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- jjdwoodman
- Offline
- User
- Live free, or die.
- Posts: 386
- Thank you received: 1
On the other hand, I would think that to have a law changed on the basis that it encroaches on his religious beliefs, he would have to prove that his religion forbids the wearing of helmets AND requires that he ride a motorcycle. Since he can choose not to ride a motorcycle and still not sin and also not break the law, he is not being persecuted.
77 650b
81 550 Mostly there
83 ZN1300 Voyager
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.